Legacy Ranches and Fine Sporting Properties

Mike McGarry's Listings

Sort Results:
Most Recent
Most Recent Price - High to Low Price - Low to High Acreage - High to Low Acreage - Low to High

Cahoen Mesa Ranch

Cortez, Colorado (Montezuma County)

  • Extensive water rights of 1,539 acre-feet irrigating up to 715 acres
  • Currently has 5 Pivots and additional side rolls
  • Water provided via McPhee Reservoir through the Dolores Water Conservancy District (DWCD)
  • Property grows primarily alfalfa hay and corn, pinto beans, orchard grass, oats and sorghum rotated in
  • Long growing season
  • Strong 4th season trophy mule deer population on the property
  • Surrounded by BLM ground on three sides
  • The Dolores River Valley has a long record of human culture and is particularly rich in the remains of the Anasazi culture
Read More
$4,100,000
970 +/- Deeded Acres
10
Price Reduced

Oak Creek Ranch

Cedaredge, Colorado (Delta County)

  • 16 Mule Deer Buck vouchers received in 2022!
  • End-of-the-road privacy adjoining the Grand Mesa National Forest and BLM
  • Pristine views of the West Elk and Ragged Wilderness, as well as the San Juan Mountains
  • Good road system throughout with year-round access
  • Excellent Elk and Mule Deer hunting opportunities
  • Good water rights irrigate meadows and an orchard
  • Several springs and ponds with Oak Creek traversing the property
  • New off-grid cabin and grass airstrip
  • 592 acres of the lower portion of the ranch is protected by a conservation easement
  • Nice amenities and healthcare 12 miles away in the quaint town of Delta
Read More
$3,700,000
1,387 +/- Deeded Acres
35

Huntsman Reserve

Ragged Mountain, Colorado (Gunnison County)

  • One of the most pristine alpine building sites in the entire Rocky Mountain West offering unparalleled privacy, views, and solitude
  • ¾ mile of creek frontage taking in both sides of Henderson Creek with its calming sound audible from multiple locations throughout the property
  • Diverse landscapes including ridges and grassy meadows interspersed throughout old-growth spruce, aspen groves, and towering dark timber
  • Incredible views of the Flattops, Grand Mesa, West Elk Wilderness, Ragged Wilderness, Marcellina Peak, Huntsman Ridge, Chair Mountain, West Beckwith Peak, and Mount Lamborn
  • One mile of National Forest adjacency on two sides and large ranch adjacency on the remaining two sides
  • Direct private access to many thousands of acres of recreational opportunities in the Gunnison National Forest which is restricted to non-motorized use in this area
  • Herds of elk, mule deer, turkeys, and numerous other bird species frequent the property
  • The property is located approximately 1.3 miles from County Road 265 which is maintained year-round
  • Approximately 1:40 from great commercial air service in either Montrose or Eagle, and the Aspen Airport and world-class skiing is approximately 1:20 away
  • Approximately 50 minutes from great amenities in Carbondale and 45 minutes away from the eclectic community of Paonia, with its ever-growing art and winery scene
Read More
$1,475,000
113 +/- Deeded Acres
16
Price Reduced

Valley Springs Ranch

Delta, Colorado (Delta County)

  • Located in the beautiful Gunnison River Valley minutes from town with year-round county-maintained paved access
  • Great fishing with 0.9 miles of Gunnison River frontage and 1.5 miles of Tongue Creek frontage
  • Great mule deer, turkey, and bird/waterfowl hunting
  • Beautiful views of the West Elk and San Juan Mountain Ranges, in addition to the Uncompahgre Plateau and the Grand Mesa
  • Approximately two hours from world-class skiing in Telluride and one hour from Powderhorn Mountain Resort on the Grand Mesa
  • Great conservation resources
  • 2.5 CFS of historic water rights
  • Fantastic recreational opportunities abound that include river rafting right in your own back yard!
Read More
$1,800,000
250 +/- Deeded Acres
27
Sold

Wilderness Homestead

Colorado (Gunnison County)

Surrounded by National Forest on all sides with a stream running through it.

Read More
$6,000,000
160 +/- Deeded Acres
2
Sold

Gib Hutchins Ranch

Somerset, Colorado (Gunnison County)

Offering historic water rights and fantastic hunting opportunities.

Read More
$2,300,000
322 +/- Deeded Acres
2
Sold

Dalia Road Farm

Olathe, Colorado (Montrose County)

  • Located on the coveted California Mesa between Montrose and Delta
  • 54 very productive irrigated acres with water rights
  • Engineered underground irrigation system with a gated pipe in place
  • ¾ of a mile of year-round creek frontage
  • Good waterfowl, upland bird, and mule deer hunting potential
  • Beautiful views of the Grand Mesa, San Juan, and West Elk Mountain Ranges
  • Located on a paved county road with electricity and domestic water in place
  • No conservation easements
Read More
$558,000
75 +/- Deeded Acres
12
Sold

Gunnison Fly-Fishing Ranch

Crawford, Colorado (Delta & Gunnison Counties)

  • Located in the majestic North Fork Valley equidistant between Aspen and Telluride and just west of Gunnison, Colorado
  • Comfortable and rustically elegant, the interiors at Smith Fork Ranch reveal the owner’s appreciation for the great traditions of the American West
  • 1.35 miles of private fishing on the Smith Fork of the Gunnison River, an additional private stream, and several ponds
  • Overlooking the West Elk Range of the Rocky Mountains, the property is surrounded by the Gunnison National Forest
  • Needle Rock Natural Area can be viewed from the home which rests beneath the Ragged and West Elk Ranges to the east, the Black Canyon of the Gunnison National Park to the south, and the Grand Mesa to the north
  • Luxurious improvements including one main residence, two guest residences, a lovingly restored lodge, three cabins, post and beam barn with apartments and stalls, and staff housing
  • Custom-designed and hand-made pieces mix with American Primitive antiques, art, rugs, and accessories from leading western and Native American artisans
  • Sporting clays/trap shooting facilities, archery range, wine cellar, spa, equestrian arena, barns and corrals
  • Unlimited recreational opportunities including fishing, hunting, hiking, mountain biking, cross country skiing, snowmobiling, swimming, and horseback riding
  • National Forest/Wilderness Area Special Use Permit for outfitting and guiding
  • Year-round access via a County maintained road
  • 1.2 hours from Montrose Regional Airport, 1.5 hours south of Carbondale
Read More
250 +/- Deeded Acres
71
Sold

Dunckley Flattops Ranch

Hayden, Colorado (Routt County)

Offering 150 acres of native grass hay meadows that are well irrigated by historic water rights.

Read More
$3,650,000
1,268 +/- Deeded Acres
2
Sold

Aspen Ridge Ranch

Cimarron, Colorado (Gunnison County)

Offering lush meadows, numerous ponds and streams, aspen groves, and timbered draws.

Read More
$3,500,000
220 +/- Deeded Acres
2
Sold

Burnt River Ranch

Beulah, Colorado (Pueblo County)

  • Unencumbered views of the majestic Wet Mountains
  • Conveniently located west of I-25 between Pueblo and the quaint town of Beulah
  • Beautiful 3,500 square foot custom home and shop
  • Custom-built horse barn with tack room, hay storage, and greenhouse
  • Grazing for approximately 25-50 head of cattle
  • Landowner hunting vouchers available for elk, mule deer, and pronghorn
  • Bird hunting opportunities include quail, dove, ducks, and geese
  • Unencumbered by any Conservation Easements
Read More
$1,450,000
560 +/- Deeded Acres
17
Sold

Little Cimarron Valley Ranch

Cimarron, Colorado (Gunnison & Montrose Counties)

  • 190+/- irrigated hay meadows and pastures, with 24+/- additional dry acres
  • Ranch includes shared use of 5.8125 CFS of irrigation water rights
  • Conveniently located 24 miles from Montrose, CO
  • Year-round access via State Highway 50 and Little Cimarron Road
  • Situated at the northern edge of the famed San Juan Mountain Range
  • Habitat for elk, mule deer, moose, bear, and turkey
  • Minutes from the Cimarron State Wildlife Area, BLM lands, and Uncompahgre National Forest
  • 15 miles from the recreational amenities of Blue Mesa Reservoir
  • Multiple areas suitable for building homes and barns
Read More
$750,000
214 +/- Deeded Acres
16
Sold

Soldier Creek Ranch

Price, Utah (Carbon County)

  • 13,233 deeded acres, plus 37,838 leased acres, with elevations ranging from 6,000 to 9,000 feet
  • Located 2 hours from Salt Lake City, Moab, and world-class skiing
  • Year-round hard surface County Road Access
  • Year-round and seasonal live water via five creeks
  • Historical water rights including numerous springs, ponds and reservoirs
  • 1,327 AUM BLM and State Grazing Allotments
  • Unencumbered by any conservation easements
  • Excellent hunting! Over-the-counter bull elk, black bear and mountain lion tags, in addition to potential landowner mule deer, cow elk and pronghorn tags
Read More
$5,500,000
13,233 +/- Deeded Acres
18

Sold Ranches

Sold

Wilderness Homestead

Colorado (Gunnison County)

Surrounded by National Forest on all sides with a stream running through it.

Read More
$6,000,000
160 +/- Deeded Acres
2
Sold

Gib Hutchins Ranch

Somerset, Colorado (Gunnison County)

Offering historic water rights and fantastic hunting opportunities.

Read More
$2,300,000
322 +/- Deeded Acres
2
Sold

Dalia Road Farm

Olathe, Colorado (Montrose County)

  • Located on the coveted California Mesa between Montrose and Delta
  • 54 very productive irrigated acres with water rights
  • Engineered underground irrigation system with a gated pipe in place
  • ¾ of a mile of year-round creek frontage
  • Good waterfowl, upland bird, and mule deer hunting potential
  • Beautiful views of the Grand Mesa, San Juan, and West Elk Mountain Ranges
  • Located on a paved county road with electricity and domestic water in place
  • No conservation easements
Read More
$558,000
75 +/- Deeded Acres
12
Sold

Gunnison Fly-Fishing Ranch

Crawford, Colorado (Delta & Gunnison Counties)

  • Located in the majestic North Fork Valley equidistant between Aspen and Telluride and just west of Gunnison, Colorado
  • Comfortable and rustically elegant, the interiors at Smith Fork Ranch reveal the owner’s appreciation for the great traditions of the American West
  • 1.35 miles of private fishing on the Smith Fork of the Gunnison River, an additional private stream, and several ponds
  • Overlooking the West Elk Range of the Rocky Mountains, the property is surrounded by the Gunnison National Forest
  • Needle Rock Natural Area can be viewed from the home which rests beneath the Ragged and West Elk Ranges to the east, the Black Canyon of the Gunnison National Park to the south, and the Grand Mesa to the north
  • Luxurious improvements including one main residence, two guest residences, a lovingly restored lodge, three cabins, post and beam barn with apartments and stalls, and staff housing
  • Custom-designed and hand-made pieces mix with American Primitive antiques, art, rugs, and accessories from leading western and Native American artisans
  • Sporting clays/trap shooting facilities, archery range, wine cellar, spa, equestrian arena, barns and corrals
  • Unlimited recreational opportunities including fishing, hunting, hiking, mountain biking, cross country skiing, snowmobiling, swimming, and horseback riding
  • National Forest/Wilderness Area Special Use Permit for outfitting and guiding
  • Year-round access via a County maintained road
  • 1.2 hours from Montrose Regional Airport, 1.5 hours south of Carbondale
Read More
250 +/- Deeded Acres
71
Sold

Dunckley Flattops Ranch

Hayden, Colorado (Routt County)

Offering 150 acres of native grass hay meadows that are well irrigated by historic water rights.

Read More
$3,650,000
1,268 +/- Deeded Acres
2
Sold

Aspen Ridge Ranch

Cimarron, Colorado (Gunnison County)

Offering lush meadows, numerous ponds and streams, aspen groves, and timbered draws.

Read More
$3,500,000
220 +/- Deeded Acres
2
Sold

Burnt River Ranch

Beulah, Colorado (Pueblo County)

  • Unencumbered views of the majestic Wet Mountains
  • Conveniently located west of I-25 between Pueblo and the quaint town of Beulah
  • Beautiful 3,500 square foot custom home and shop
  • Custom-built horse barn with tack room, hay storage, and greenhouse
  • Grazing for approximately 25-50 head of cattle
  • Landowner hunting vouchers available for elk, mule deer, and pronghorn
  • Bird hunting opportunities include quail, dove, ducks, and geese
  • Unencumbered by any Conservation Easements
Read More
$1,450,000
560 +/- Deeded Acres
17
Sold

Little Cimarron Valley Ranch

Cimarron, Colorado (Gunnison & Montrose Counties)

  • 190+/- irrigated hay meadows and pastures, with 24+/- additional dry acres
  • Ranch includes shared use of 5.8125 CFS of irrigation water rights
  • Conveniently located 24 miles from Montrose, CO
  • Year-round access via State Highway 50 and Little Cimarron Road
  • Situated at the northern edge of the famed San Juan Mountain Range
  • Habitat for elk, mule deer, moose, bear, and turkey
  • Minutes from the Cimarron State Wildlife Area, BLM lands, and Uncompahgre National Forest
  • 15 miles from the recreational amenities of Blue Mesa Reservoir
  • Multiple areas suitable for building homes and barns
Read More
$750,000
214 +/- Deeded Acres
16
Sold

Soldier Creek Ranch

Price, Utah (Carbon County)

  • 13,233 deeded acres, plus 37,838 leased acres, with elevations ranging from 6,000 to 9,000 feet
  • Located 2 hours from Salt Lake City, Moab, and world-class skiing
  • Year-round hard surface County Road Access
  • Year-round and seasonal live water via five creeks
  • Historical water rights including numerous springs, ponds and reservoirs
  • 1,327 AUM BLM and State Grazing Allotments
  • Unencumbered by any conservation easements
  • Excellent hunting! Over-the-counter bull elk, black bear and mountain lion tags, in addition to potential landowner mule deer, cow elk and pronghorn tags
Read More
$5,500,000
13,233 +/- Deeded Acres
18
Ranch Updates
Search
Filter Your Selection Below or Filter Ranches on Map
Ranch Status
Price Range

Adjust slider to see a specific price range.

Locations
Press to toggle on/off
Acreage

Adjust slider to see a specific acreage range.

Ranch Type
Press to toggle on/off
OR

Type any word of phrase to find relevant properties and articles (ex: "Trees Ranch" or "trophy elk")

Can't find your dream ranch? Click here for our Buyer Services

Can't find your dream ranch?
Our comprehensive buyer service can help
Find out more